Best Striper Trolling Lures Freshwater [2022 Review]

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Trolling for and catching stripers, such as striped bass, can be pretty frustrating especially if you are not using the right equipment. A key ingredient in your success when trolling in freshwater is the lure type that you choose to use, particularly if you are trolling for stripers. This is because getting the best stripper trolling lures for freshwater can up your chances of a good haul.

Our Top Freshwater Striper Trolling Lures Recommendations

There is definitely a frightening amount of striper trolling lures for freshwater angling, and choosing the best can be quite the herculean task. Our well-researched, tested, and carefully selected lures can make all the difference that you are seeking:

Brand
Tony Maja Magic Mojo 9
The Storm WildEye Shad Swimbaits
SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbaits
Product
Tony Maja - Striper Killer Maja Magic Mojo 9-in...
Storm WildEye Swim Shad 03 (Golden Mullet, Size-...
SZJP Fishing Lures for Bass 5.5 inch 8 Segment...
Material
Plastic
Lead
Plastic
Item Dimensions
‎9.8 x 9.5 x 1.4 inches
‎4.8 x 3.1 x 0.7 inches
‎5.71 x 3.35 x 1.38 inches
Brand
Tony Maja Magic Mojo 9
Product
Tony Maja - Striper Killer Maja Magic Mojo 9-in...
Material
Plastic
Item Dimensions
‎9.8 x 9.5 x 1.4 inches
Brand
The Storm WildEye Shad Swimbaits
Product
Storm WildEye Swim Shad 03 (Golden Mullet, Size-...
Material
Lead
Item Dimensions
‎4.8 x 3.1 x 0.7 inches
Brand
SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbaits
Product
SZJP Fishing Lures for Bass 5.5 inch 8 Segment...
Material
Plastic
Item Dimensions
‎5.71 x 3.35 x 1.38 inches

Best Freshwater Striper Trolling Lure Overall: Tony Maja Magic Mojo 9

Tony Maja - Striper Killer Maja Magic Mojo 9-in...

If you’re looking for the ultimate striper killer, the Tony Maja Magic Mojo 9 is the way to go. This bait comes with a ready-to-use spoon and maybe trolled with braids, lines, and other accessories. This lure’s spoons are made of strong stainless steel, making them great for both surface and deep freshwater striper fishing.

They can easily cruise the depths of rivers and other open waters in search of stripers hiding in the depths, ensuring you a good catch. The Tony Maja hook could also boast a couple of specific benefits. It boosts your hook-up ratio, and unlike the Storm Wildeye Shad Swimbaits, where the hooks are not replaceable, the Tony Maja’s hooks can be replaced if they become damaged, ensuring continued use.

Also, while we are on the subject of Tony Maja’s durability, the product is mostly built of stainless steel, making it a match for large stripers because it can endure their savage attacks, unlike the Storm WildEye Shad, which has a PVC body. However, while the Tony Maja is our overall best lure, it goes without saying that it is mostly suited to pro anglers.

Pros

  • It is made of stainless steel, which boosts its durability
  • When parts are broken, they can be replaced, which encourages long-term use

Cons

  • It may not be very suitable for surface trolling since it is better suited to depths
  • It may not be suited to be used by amateur anglers
Tony Maja - Striper Killer Maja Magic Mojo 9-in...
  • 32-Ounce TONY MAJA MAGIC MOJO 9" SHAD RIG (White)
  • #3 TONY MAJA BUNKER / HERRING CUSTOM BUNKER SPOON (Chartreuse/Green)
  • Comes with 150# leader 320# coast lock swivels and 3 way swivel.

Best Versatile Striper Trolling Lure: Storm Wildeye Shad Swimbaits

Storm WildEye Swim Shad 03 (Golden Mullet, Size-...

The Storm WildEye Shad Swimbaits are a must-have on your lure list if you’re seeking a lure that allows you to explore deep seas for stripers and is colorful enough to entice this fish species.

The Storm Wildeye Shad Swimbaits are well-known for their effectiveness in catching striped bass. Their color attracts these fish, and this bait works well in both topwater and deep water. While the Cotton Cordell can only travel 6 feet below the water surface, the Storm WildEye shad swimbaits can go up to 12 feet below the surface, allowing you to catch stripers all day.

The light PVC body of this lure allows fishermen to cast it for longer distances with ease. A 3D sheet beneath the PVC body of this lure attracts stripers as you recover it. Unlike the Cotton Cordwell, which has six hooks, and the Blue Water Candy, which has nine hooks, the Storm Wildeye Shad Swimbaits only have one hook.

This single hook increases the likelihood of your catch coming off, which is a downside of this lure. When retrieving your bait, you would need to go easy in order to avoid losing your catch.

Pros

  • It’s bright and vibrant, making it easy to attract stripers
  • It’s lightweight, which encourages longer-distance casting and makes it easier for anglers to transport

Cons

  • It has only one hook, which limits the number of stripers you may catch and increases the risk of your catch leaving the hook as you recover it
  • When a portion of the lure breaks, it cannot be replaced
Storm WildEye Swim Shad 03 (Golden Mullet, Size-...
  • These ultra-realistic swim shad baits feature super-soft hand-poured bodies that are so lifelike,...
  • Sporting strong soft bodies with internal lead heads and bio-salt impregnated tails
  • These durable baits are pre-rigged with a superior VMC needle point hooks. 3 per pack

Best Topwater Striper Trolling Lure: SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbaits

SZJP Fishing Lures for Bass 5.5 inch 8 Segment...

If you enjoy topwater fishing early in the morning or late in the evening when the weather is cool, you’ll need a lure that supports topwater fishing, and the SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbaits is the lure for you. This lure was designed to readily pass as a little fish in the eyes of stripers, which led to the inclusion of 3D fish eyes. This is in contrast to the Storm Wildeye’s 3D prints beneath the PVC body.

It also has a tough ABS plastic body that is divided into seven sections and can readily submerge into the water when thrown, swimming in an S-motion like other fish. This increases the likelihood of your catching a fish since stripers and other fish species will be enticed to bite your bait.

The lure comes with six sections, each with two sturdy treble hooks, unlike the Blue Water Candy, which is a six-arm umbrella. It is vital to remember that these lures cannot be repaired if the hook is damaged or lost, which is a downside.

Finally, the SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbait weighs 0.97 ounces and is sturdy, ensuring that your lure does not get spoiled during a ferocious striper fight.

Pros

  • It is made of hard ABS plastic, making it durable against vicious attacks
  • Each piece comes with a strong hook, ensuring that you don’t lose your catch along the way 

Cons

  • Lures and hooks can’t be repaired after damage, costing you more to buy a new lure if the one you have gets damaged
  • Mainl supports only topwater trolling and is not useful for depths
SZJP Fishing Lures for Bass 5.5 inch 8 Segment...
  • 🐟Including: 6 pcs fishing lures with a Tackle Box, every fishing lure Rigged with 2 super sharp...
  • 🐟Lifelike Swimbait:Designed with seven segmented body sections, it can sink slowly and moves...
  • 🐟Aetificial lure of high simulation:3D printing body with perfect pearl powder coating....

Best Umbrella Rig Striper Trolling Lure: Blue Water Candy Striperbrella Umbrella Rig with Parachute

Blue Water Candy Striperbrella Umbrella Rig with...

The Blue Water Candy Umbrella Rig is a great bait for catching stripers in both saltwater and freshwater. This product was designed with an emphasis on the lure’s efficacy and longevity, and it has shown to be a very effective striper catcher.

This umbrella rig weighs only 0.16 ounces, which is significantly less than the cotton Cordell Big 0 at 0.03 ounces. Despite its lighter weight, this lure is still capable of attracting large stripers while incurring little or no damage.

This lure has a 6-arm umbrella with 6-inch shag bodies on each arm, making it highly effective. This looks like a school of fish and is quite successful at luring stripers who are looking for a meal. Unlike the Cotton Cordell which has seven hooks, the Blue Water Candy has nine. However, some of these hooks may fail, resulting in the loss of your striper, which is a downside of this lure.

With a 4-ounce core weight, this umbrella rig can withstand a punch while retrieving the lure for a catch. It also comes in different colors, particularly the chartreuse and it is properly colored, unlike the Cotton Cordell. This color is quite effective in attracting stripers, increasing your chances of a good catch.

Pros

  • Brightly colored in chartreuse, which attracts fish and increases the chances of a good catch
  • It is a sturdy rig, which ensures that you aren’t replacing your lure every time
  • It comes with nine hooks, giving you a lot of options and a greater chance to catch more stripers

Cons

  • Some of the hooks may not hold, leading to the loss of your catch
  • You would likely need a lot more teasers to make your umbrella rig more effective underwater
Blue Water Candy Striperbrella Umbrella Rig with...
  • Package length: 32.512 cm
  • Package width: 29.718 cm
  • Package height: 2.794 cm

Best Crankbait Striper Trolling Lure: Cotton Cordell Big O Squarebill

Cotton Cordell Big O Square-Lip Crankbait Fishing...

Among seasoned fishers, the Cotton Cordell Big O Squarebill isn’t a new striper catcher. However, with a new body and a one-of-a-kind cover-deflecting ability, this lure becomes a terrific addition to your arsenal. The length and depth to which the lure can dive when used are the main variations between the three types of crankbaits. The Big O C76, which is 2 inches long, cannot reach deeper than 4 feet in the water.

The C77, which is 2-1/4 inches long, cannot reach deeper than 5 feet in the water. The C78, the largest of the group, is 3 inches long and can only go 6 feet below the water surface. The Cotton Cordell Big O is a good lure for both shallow and deep water striper fishing, while the ACME Kastmaster covers a wider range of depths. This crankbait has a size 6 hook, which is recognized for holding on to your fish precisely.

 These hooks, like the ACME Kastmaster, aren’t well sharpened, so you would end up with a blunt hook that needs to be sharpened or replaced after a while. This is the lure to use if you want to fish in shallow water. When shaken forcefully, it may readily simulate a wounded fish, and despite the lure’s poor coloration, which is a downside, it still has the appropriate colors to attract stripers.

Pros

  • It is quite comfortable to move around, weighing just 0.3oz
  • It comes with six fishing hooks, allowing you to catch more stripers

Cons

  • Hooks might need sharpening or replacement after a short while
  • The lure is poorly colored, reducing the effectiveness
Cotton Cordell Big O Square-Lip Crankbait Fishing...
  • The Big O is the original square-lip crankbait and sold more than one million lures during its first...
  • It is known as one of fishing's most-copied lures, but no other bait captures that shimmy and...
  • Equally effective in lakes and streams, the Big O truly is one of fishing's most legendary lures. It...

Best Metal Slab Striper Trolling Lure: ACME Kastmaster

Acme Kastmaster Fishing Lure, Chrome, 1 oz.

The ACME Kastmaster has proven to be a reliable striper catcher throughout the years. It has a simple design and, when in the water, it imitates a wounded fish, drawing worthy predators. It is a lure that is recognized for casting vast distances, which makes it a popular choice among anglers.

The ACME Kastmaster is highly robust, as it is composed of solid brass rather than the soft body of the Storm’s Wildeye Shad swimbait. This robust body won’t bend or break when you’re fishing in freshwater bodies and guarantees that you can use your bait again, even if your capture has attacked it viciously.

In addition, as compared to other lures and metal slabs, the ACME Kastmaster tends to have blunt hooks, which is its single major flaw. The lure’s retrieving mechanism, on the other hand, provides a significant advantage, enhancing the chances of a successful catch. The ACME Kastmaster, on the other hand, can readily extract a catch thanks to its robust hooks, guaranteeing that it does not come off. This lure goes deeper into the water than the Storm’s Wildeye Shad swimbait, giving you a better chance to catch those stripers hiding in the depths, especially on sunny days.

Pros

  • It is durable and can withstand the attacks of big stripers without experiencing major damage
  • It allows for a longer cast distance for anglers, giving you a better chance at nailing a big fish

Cons

  • This lure has hooks that would need regular sharpening and eventual replacement
  • The weight of this lure makes it uncomfortable for anglers on a long run
Acme Kastmaster Fishing Lure, Chrome, 1 oz.
  • Field tested by expert anglers
  • Made to last
  • Built using the highest quality materials

Features to Consider for Striper Trolling Lures

Before buying that striper trolling lure, there are some features that you must look out for ranging from size, strength, and color. These features go a long way in determining how much you would get from a lure.

Lure typeTopwater and DeepwaterMetal SlabTopwaterCrankbaitUmbrella RigTopwater and deep water 
Tony MajaThe ACMESZJP MultiCotton CordellBlue Water CandyStorm Wildeye
Lure Size3 inches2.3 inches 5.3 inches2 / 2¼ / 3 inches6 inches3 inches
Lure ColorChartreuse/white/green (others available)Silver/gold/bronzeMulticolorGolden MulletChartreuseRainbow Trout (7+ available)

Lure Size and Lure Strength

When attempting to catch stripers, keep in mind that these fish can weigh up to 40 pounds, and in rare circumstances, you may be dealing with a striper weighing more than 40 pounds. This means you would need a lure that packs a punch and is large enough to match the size and strength of your catch.

An image of trolling lure for freshwater

Striped bass is a fish that is known for biting strongly. They aren’t about to give up without a fight. You would need a lure with robust hooks, like the Cotton Cordell, which has been known to endure vicious striper bites.

Due to the large size of these stripers, your lure must be between 6 and 10 inches long just like the Blue Water Candy Umbrella Rig to be effective. This ensures that your catch, no matter how large, is not lost.

Lure Color

Coloration is one of the most well-known characteristics of top lures. The brighter they are, the more appealing they are to stripers. If you want to buy a lure, look for chartreuse-colored baits like the Tony Maja, as well as white, yellow, and black.

White and black are the same colors that live bait would be, luring stripers in for a bite. While chartreuse and yellow are well-known for their ability to stand out on open water. Stripers are naturally attracted to their hues.

Choose brighter colored lures like yellow, blue, red, pink, or a combination of most or all of them, such as the SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbaits, if you want to catch stripers in deeper water.

Lure Type

The type of lure is the final factor to consider before purchasing your lure. Stripers enjoy feeding, and they appreciate having their prey come to them without being stressed, which makes them vulnerable. However, knowing what you want to achieve, whether you want to fish at the surface or in the depths, will help you choose the right lure.

There are a number of different lure types to choose from:

Topwater Lures

These are the most popular lures among anglers. They are best for striper fishing in the early mornings and evenings. Stripers come to the surface during these periods, and you may simply entice them with your lures and catch them. Your best bet for a satisfying topwater fishing experience is the SZJP Multi Jointed Swimbaits.

CrankBait

This is a lure that has been carefully formed to dive and stay submerged in the water. Because it has a flat lip at the top, this is conceivable. The bodies of these lures are known to be short and plump. The Cotton Cordell is a high-quality topwater and deep-water crankbait.

A person holding a trolling lure

Umbrella Jigs

When the weather gets hot, you would need an umbrella jig to get to the deepest parts of the water, where stripers are known to retire as the sun rises. Stripers are attracted to these jigs because they resemble schools of fish. This is where the Blue Water Candy Umbrella Rig comes in.

Metal Slab

When it comes to the depths, where umbrella jigs are ineffective, a metal slab is required. This is a beaten-up metal slab in the shape of a fish. It comes in a variety of sizes, and you’ll need a lot of them to catch those stripers hiding in the undergrowth and the murky waterways. The ACME Kastmaster is a good example.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Are Some Striper Lures Fishing Techniques?

There are several fishing lure tactics used when fishing for stripers. However, we will be looking at two of these techniques:

Walking the Dog Technique

This entails retrieving your striper bait in a zigzag motion and bringing it back to you. This imitates a wounded fish and attracts predators, such as striped bass in this example. What’s the best way to make this zigzag motion?

Pulling your lure with your fishing rod, bending down the tip, and reeling in the surplus line is how you accomplish it. To create the zigzag motion, you’ll need to leave a bit of line to allow your bait to jump and settle. Once you’ve gotten the hang of it and your lure is moving in a zigzag pattern, retrieve it and repeat as many times as you can.

Once you’ve mastered it, accelerating it up enhances your chances of landing a catch. You should be aware that this technique works best when the water is calm and there are few waves or disturbances. As a result, go fishing on a quiet day with a little breeze. Stripers might be attracted to calm seas.

The Striper Tease Technique

You would get angry because these stripers are ignoring your appealing lures at times, and you would wonder where you went wrong. But it does happen, which is when the striper tease tactic comes in handy.

A teaser is used shortly before your main bait with this strategy. This teaser could include feathers, plastic fish, and bucktails, among other things. While a teaser reduces cast distance, it is quite successful in catching and trapping bass.

If you want to catch stripers that stay in the water depths or stripers that hide behind thick vegetation, you would need a heavy teaser. If you’re fishing in shallow water, however, a small teaser will suffice.

What Is the Best Time to Fish For Striped Bass?

Striped bass fishing is most ideal early in the morning until about 120 minutes after sunrise, and late in the afternoon until about two hours before sunset. When you fish for bass a few hours before it rains or on a cool morning, you can also make a huge catch. Generally speaking, cloudy/cool weather is ideal.

A top view image of a trolling lure

Knowing what the optimum time is to fish for stripers reduces the impatience you would experience in open waters and makes you a better striper fisherman.

During the day, striped bass is more active than at night. This is because they can see better than their prey during this time. As a result, now is the greatest time to go fishing for them.

How Do You Fish for Stripers at Night?

There are two major steps to fishing for stripers at night:

Get Proper Gear for Night Fishing

The first step is to get the necessary striper night fishing equipment. You’ll need not only your lures and line but also a headlamp or boat lights if you have them. The more lights you have surrounding the area where you wish to fish, the more bait you will locate, which will result in a great catch.

If you want to go the extra mile and do some live baiting, you would also need cast nets, plus a spotlight to detect channels and see your fish as soon as your lures get them. This light, however, must not be tampered with to avoid getting blinded.

Select the Right Area

The next stage is to successfully catch a striper after selecting a decent area with sharp drops and good depths. In most cases, diving plugs, live baiting, and jigs come in handy. It’s also vital to have only dark-colored lures with you. Deep crimson, purple, and black lures are particularly effective.

You can drop a bait just a few feet below the light while your lights are on the water, providing illumination for these fish. Stripers are known to come up a bit above the dark depths to feed, and this would be your opportunity to catch them, making your night unforgettable.

Conclusion

Getting a striper is a challenging undertaking, and it becomes even more difficult if you don’t have the right fishing lure. This particular gear can make all the difference, and you can jolly well be on your way to making major hauls.